6H. Case Study #5: Missoula, Montana
The original version of this Campaign Guide was produced by the North Carolina Department of Transportation Bicycle Program in cooperation with the Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources Office for Prevention, the Center for Disease Control, the University of North Carolina Highway Safety Research Center and the State Office of 4-H and Youth Development. Text, layout, and information were developed by John Williams, then of Bikecentennial, which has become Adventure Cycling. John is now with Tracy-Williams Consulting, and if your Internet connection is working they have an amazingly useful Web page for bicycle planners. The case studies in this manual were written by Gary MacFadden of Adventure Cycling and Kathleen McLaughlin. Funding for the original project was provided by the Federal Highway Administration through the Transportation Improvement Program. The manual was updated and posted on the Web by Randy Swart of the Bicycle Helmet Safety Institute, without funding from anybody, but with help from John Williams, in 1997. It has been updated at least annually since, with a refresh date at the top.
California's manual for school-based programs
If you are conducting a school program, you should use the manual written specifically for that purpose by the State of California. Some of it is California-specific, but it will be worth your while to check it out. The material below will still be useful, no matter what your campaign target is. And don't miss the Dublin, Ohio kids helmet promotion campaign below.
1. Bicycle helmet campaigns do good things.
Want to do something about bicycle safety in your town? Something that can save lives and prevent many needless injuries?
Why not try a bicycle helmet campaign! Bicycle safety has many parts, but there are few things that can make as much difference in a bicyclist's safety as a helmet. Unfortunately, many people don't know how important one is. They may not have ever tried a helmet on or seen one up close. Others have just not thought about helmets, think they are expensive, or have been postponing a decision. That's where you come in!
A bicycle helmet campaign ties in well with the current concern about reducing obeisity. Schools and health departments are looking for ways to promote healthy physical activity for both youth and adults. Keeping your weight within a reasonable range is important for health, and bicycling can help. Bicycling safely and wearing a helmet while you bicycle are important too. The concerns can be addressed together.
A good bicycle helmet campaign will educate the public--children, parents, adult bicyclists--to the need for head protection. In many communities, this means overcoming apathy. While that may not be easy, the results are gratifying. Seeing the need for head protection often raises other questions about how to make the cycling environment safer.
Once people see the need, they must be able to get helmets. Although this is not an issue in many communities where good quality helmets are available at low cost from retail outlets, some campaigns work with local bike dealers to arrange good deals on quality helmets. In addition, many pursue special campaign prices and, in some cases, print discount coupons for consumers.
The bottom line, however, is results: saving lives and preventing serious injuries. And it's been shown that bicycle helmet campaigns can have a real effect on safety and injury prevention.
A study from the Harborview Injury Prevention Center in Seattle, Washington, found that bike helmets could prevent three out of four cycling deaths. A follow-up study published in 1996 and available here if your Internet connection is up, confirmed that. And one state's helmet campaigns led to a 20 percent drop in hospitalization due to bike-related head injuries.
What do people do in their helmet campaigns? Here are five ideas that have increased awareness of bike helmets:
- A PTA leader got local bike shops to donate sample helmets for use in school bike safety programs.
- A Safe Kids Coalition got a major manufacturer to offer very low prices on helmets sold in local schools.
- A bicycle program got together with the few kids who wore helmets and the local TV station, and filmed several bike safety Public Service Announcements.
- A parent put together a safety-and-helmet puppet show and took it to all elementary
schools in town.
- A local radio station's disc jockey gave away prizes to all helmeted riders he saw while driving around town.
- A church program was supported by the minister, who wore a bike helmet while preaching his sermon!
These are just a few of the many ideas being tried around the country. Throughout this manual you will find many others, along with suggestions on how to come up with your own. And it contains the background you'll need on helmet basics.
Why not get involved in promoting bicycle helmet use in your area? Helmets really do make a difference!
Eight Sobering Bicycle Crash Facts
1. About 800 Americans die each year in bicycle crashes.
2. Using a helmet could save about 680 of them.
3. About 500 are younger than 18.
4. Over 500,000 visit a doctor after a bike crash.
5. Only about 5% of all serious bicycling injuries involve cars.
6. 40,000 injury-producing bike-car collisions are reported.
7. About 40,000 more go unreported.
8. Most car-bike crashes happen on quiet neighborhood streets.
Those are shocking numbers: riders need helmets now! Then we need to work on the road environment to make it safer.
2. All about heads and bicycle helmets
Before discussing bicycle helmet campaigns, let's first look at some important aspects of bicycle helmets and answer a few basic questions.
Aren't helmets just for serious riders?
Bike helmets are for all riders. Nasty bicycle crashes can happen to anyone, anytime, anywhere, and at any speed. Parents may think their children are safe riding around the neighborhood. But research tells us that most serious bicycle crashes occur on quiet neighborhood streets. This is especially true for young children. And nearly 30% of all cycling deaths happen on residential streets.
In addition, even simple falls can lead to life-threatening injuries. According to a study of North Carolina emergency rooms, one out of four serious bicycling injuries is a head injury. And roughly one out of three head injury crashes don't involve cars.
In about half of all bicycling crashes the rider's head hits a solid object: perhaps a car, the pavement, or a curb. Such crashes can easily cause brain or skull damage.
What's so special about head injuries?
Nationwide, nearly 50,000 bicyclists suffer serious head injuries each year. Many never fully recover. Broken bones or "road rash" can heal readily but a head injury can lead to death or disability.
To understand why, lets look at the brain and how it's protected. What follows is condensed from a brochure from the United States Cycling Federation.
The outermost layer of the head, the scalp, is the first line of defense; underneath this is the hard bony skull. The brain itself floats in cerebral spinal fluid, a slippery liquid, and is surrounded by a thin membrane, the dura. The brain joins the spinal cord at the brain stem. Through this junction, messages pass from the brain to the body and back again. The brain is the control center for the body and, as a result, brain damage can affect how--and if--a person's body works.
There are three main types of brain injuries: concussions, contusions and hemorrhages.
Concussions happen when the brain gets "shaken up" and
stops working for a while. Usually, things soon return to normal.
However, in a severe concussion, permanent damage can occur.
Contusions are bruises caused when the brain hits the rough inside surface of the skull.
Hemorrhages happen in severe cases, when the brain bleeds. If this happens, the brain can get squeezed because there's no place for the blood to go in the closed skull. This internal bleeding can easily lead to death or permanent brain damage, even though the cyclist may seem ok for days or weeks.
In addition, the skull may be fractured. While a skull fracture might not be serious, pieces of bone may pierce the dura and damage the brain.
Because the brain is so important, even mild injuries can cause
serious problems. Loss of memory, increased irritability, odd
changes in personality, inability to hold a tennis racket... these and many more things can happen to people who hit their heads in a crash.
What the research says
Findings of a study reported in the Cochrane Collaboration in 2009:
Bicycle riders with helmets had...
- Helmets provide a 66 to 88% reduction in the risk of head, brain and severe brain injury for all ages of bicyclists. Helmets provide equal levels of protection for crashes involving motor vehicles (69%) and crashes from all other causes (68%). Injuries to the upper and mid facial areas are reduced 65%.
- Helmets reduce bicycle-related head and facial injuries for bicyclists of all ages involved in all types of crashes, including those involving motor vehicles.
Conclusion: Bicycle safety helmets are highly effective in preventing head injury and are particularly important to children, since they suffer the majority of serious head injuries from bicycling crashes.
How can bicycle helmets help?
The brain needs protection. When a person rides a bicycle, the best protection comes from a bike helmet.
A bicycle helmet can't keep someone from falling off a bike. It can't keep a car from hitting you. But it can cut the chances of serious brain injury. It does this by cushioning the blow that otherwise would hit the skull and brain in a crash. In doing so, the foam liner of the helmet is crushed between the object (car, curb, roadway) and the rider's head; in other words, it "self-destructs" in order to protect what's inside. The foam in most helmets does not recover. This is why any helmet that has been crashed should be replaced and not used again, even if it appears to be in good shape. There's no way for the user to tell just how much protection is left. (A few helmets made of a special foam called EPP for Expanded PolyPropylene do recover, and can be used again.) We have never heard a rider who trashed a helmet in a crash complain about the cost of replacing it!
We know that helmets do protect. As noted above, researchers say that bicycle helmets could prevent between 63 and 88 per cent of all serious head injuries to bike riders. And, since about 75% of all cycling deaths are due to head injuries, helmet use could save many lives each year. That's a worthwhile investment for any bicyclist, young or old.
What makes up a bike helmet?
Every bicycle helmet contains a dense liner made from stiff crushable foam. This liner crushes and manages the impact energy in a crash. Most helmets protect this liner with a plastic shell, which helps hold the foam together in a crash and improves the slipperiness of the helmet so it will not "stick" to the pavement. The straps and buckle keep the helmet from flying off during a crash sequence before the rider hits the pavement. There may be a stabilizer in the back as well to improve the helmet's stability while riding, but the strap does the work of holding the helmet on in a crash. All parts of the helmet work together to prevent injury.
Keep in mind that for a helmet to work properly, it must fit and be adjusted correctly. If it is out of position when the rider hits, bare head may be exposed to the impact! See Parent's Tip #2 below for information on correct size and fit. And check out this page on how hairdo's and baseball caps affect fit.
How can you be sure a helmet is tough?
All helmets sold in the U.S. since 1999 must by law meet the standard published by the US Consumer Product Safety Commission. There will be a sticker in the helmet certifying that it meets the CPSC standard. That means it meets impact and coverage requirements.
The CPSC tests require putting metal headforms inside the helmets and dropping them on hard surfaces. The helmets must manage most of the impact, allowing only a small amount to get through. Helmets that don't pass don't get certified.
Consumer Reports tests bicycle helmets every two or three years. Their articles never include as many models as we would like, but they are the only independent source of published performance ratings, so we have included our review of their latest article on this disk.
What about comfort and weight?
Today's bicycle helmets weigh between 7 and 14 ounces-about as much as a wool sweater. This is much lighter than the helmets sold back in the 90's. Since helmets have been required in bicycle racing in the U.S. since 1986, manufacturers have worked hard to cut the weight of their models, and to increase ventilation. That's an improvement that has benefited everyone.
Weight is also important for infants riding in child seats; their necks could be strained by heavy helmets. As a result, infant helmets are designed to be very light as well, even though they have increased coverage.
With older kids weight probably isn't as critical as durability. But the perception of a light helmet is important to almost any user. Riders of any age just will not use a helmet they think of as heavy.
How much does a helmet cost?
Bicycle helmets are cheap! In the 1990's prices dropped like a stone. The manufacturers are still crying the blues, but for consumers it has been a buyer's market ever since. You can still pay over a hundred dollars for a helmet if you want the latest thing that Lance Armstrong used in the Tour de France, but in discount stores it is not unusual to find decent helmets at $10 to $25, and even in bike stores there is usually a fine helmet around $30. Bike stores offer a valuable service: they will fit your helmet properly. That's worth a lot, since fit makes a big difference in how much protection a helmet gives you. But helmets are available for helmet campaigns at very low prices: check out our latest update on inexpensive helmets for more info.
The Bicycle Helmet Safety Institute submitted samples of six helmet models to a leading U.S. test lab: three in the $150+ range and three under $20. The impact test results were virtually identical. There were very few differences in performance among the helmets. Although the sample was small, the testing indicates that the consumer can shop for a bicycle helmet in the US market without undue concern about the impact performance of the various models, whatever the price level. The most important advice is to find a helmet that fits you well so that it will be positioned correctly when you hit.
We never want to lose sight of the fact that what a helmet protects is priceless: a cyclist's life and future. But lower priced helmets can make all the difference in a successful helmet campaign!
For those who have suffered brain injuries, rehabilitation is a very costly and difficult challenge. Here are some facts from
the National Head Injury Foundation:
- Each severe head injury survivor requires between $4.1
million and $9 million dollars in care over a lifetime.
- The typical survivor of severe head injury requires
between five and ten years of intensive rehabilitation.
- There are 2,000 cases of persistent vegetative state
in the United States every year caused by head injury.
While facts are useful, they don't measure the personal cost.
Here is what Mark Guydish of the Velonauts Bicycle Club said about his brother's tragic traffic accident:
Michael's accident, his transformation from a kind, young vibrant man to a stuporous, child-like being in need of long, hard therapy, has taught me one lesson acutely: there is nothing greater a human being can lose than a mind, and nothing he should value more.
Compare these costs--in terms of both dollars and human suffering--with the cost of a helmet and you will see how good a bargain a helmet is. Remember, too, that a good helmet will last for years, as long as it's never crashed. That's more than you can say for a pair of sneakers!
Will people wear helmets?
Starting a new safety habit can be hard, both for the individual
and for the group. That was true when they brought in hockey helmets, football helmets, motorcycle helmets, and many other protective measures. And it's true now of bicycle helmets. In a typical town, it will take time to make helmets popular. One study, done in Wisconsin, found that few bicyclists had thought about wearing a helmet. Another survey, done in Pitt County, North Carolina, found very few who wore bicycle helmets.
But times are changing. Nation wide, several million bicyclists
now own and wear helmets when they ride their bicycles. With gentle but firm encouragement, more will join the growing helmet movement. In some communities with active helmet encouragement programs, helmet use has grown from less than one percent to over 35 percent. The program in Seattle, Washington, is perhaps the best known and has enjoyed enormous success. There, more than 65 percent of all bicyclists wear helmets. There are active local programs in many other communities. Safe Kids USA mounted its second national bicycle helmet campaign in 2002. If you are working with kids and have a local Safe Kids Coalition they can be a source of help.
Parent's Tip #1: Choosing a Bicycle Helmet
Make sure it can be adjusted to fit. Fine tuning the fit with foam pads and strap adjustments should make it fit snugly but not be tight. It should sit level on the head and shouldn't rock from side to side or front to back.
Make sure it meets the standard. Look for a sticker inside that says it meets the CPSC standard. (Required by law for a bike helmet.)
Make sure it has adequate ventilation. Kids using BMX or skate helmets don't seem to care about sweaty heads, but the rest of us need adequate front vents to permit air flow.
Make sure the child likes it. It's a lot easier to get
a child to wear a helmet if he or she helped pick it out and likes it. If they think it's geeky, you may have helmet wars!
Remember: helmets aren't forever. Since a helmet uses itself up
saving your child's life, it makes sense to replace it after a
crash. You may not even be able to see the damage but it's better
to be safe than sorry. And at some point, your child may outgrow
a helmet. Heads grow less than arms and legs, and you can extend its life by using thinner sizing pads, but the time will come. The Maine retrofit program can help with ideas for extending helmet life.
Bicyclists are their own engines and produce heat; a lot of
this heat radiates out through the head. As a result, helmet ventilation is important--especially on long rides on hot days. It's possible to get overheated and dizzy while riding in the summer heat with a poorly-ventilated helmet. For this reason, bicyclists who do more than neighborhood cruising or riding to school should look closely at how well the helmet cools. All current helmets have slots or holes to let in air. Although the number of openings may be a sales point, it is mostly the size of the front vents that determines how cool a helmet will be.
Is it important to keep the head cool?
Some toddler helmets don't have ventilation. That may be ok in mild weather, since the child is most often carried in a child seat or trailer and isn't as likely to overheat. But in warm weather a toddler needs ventilation too.
Some BMX racing helmets do not have ventilation either. BMX events are short, and the kids like the motorcycle helmet look, so they don't insist on vents. Skate helmets have minimal vents, but again the kids insist on the style.
What about looks and fashion?
Way back in the 80's, bicycle helmets looked like buckets or
ugly mushrooms. They were hot, often uncomfortable, and weighed a ton. But not today! Using modern materials and designs, manufacturers have created protective helmets that look great, feel light and cool and protect better! They come in all sorts of fashion colors with great looking covers and graphics. Some come with stickers your child can use to personalize them. And there's a style to suit nearly everyone.
Parent's Tip #2: Fitting your child's helmet
1. First, get the right sized helmet. Helmets come in sizes from Small to Extra Large. Each size fits a range of head sizes. Find one that fits comfortably and doesn't pinch. Let your child try the helmets on.
2. Use the sizing pads for a comfortable fit. Most helmets
come with different sized foam pads. Use these to "fine tune"
the helmet's fit to your child's head shape.
3. Finally, adjust the straps for a snug fit. The helmet
should sit level on the head, cover the forehead down to the eyebrows and not rock back and forth or side to side. Helmets have adjustable straps to help you get them level and snug. The adjustments are fussy, so be prepared to spend a few minutes doing it.
Parent's Tip #3: Taking care of your child's helmet
1. Be careful using paint or stickers on a helmet. Some
paints and stickers can damage a bicycle helmet. Don't use
anything on it unless you are sure it's safe. Some bike shops
sell bright reflective stickers that are safe on helmets. Check
2. Clean the helmet with gentle soap and warm water. A helmet gets pretty dirty over time and it's nice to clean it up. But don't use solvents or cleansers! These can damage the helmet, even though the damage might not be visible. Hand soap or dish washing liquid are fine.
3. Treat a helmet with respect and care. While a it is made to take knocks, excessive abuse can damage it. It's best not to waste its strength by tossing it around or kicking it.
Parents Tip #4: How to get a child to wear a helmet
A bicycle helmet may take some getting used to at first. Even
the lightest models may not feel natural until the rider gets used to wearing them. These tips will help parents encourage the helmet habit in their children.
1. Let your child help pick out the helmet. After all,
he or she is the one who will be wearing it. If your child enjoys decorating personal items, look for one of the helmets that comes with stickers they can apply, or buy some helmet-friendly stickers separately. (Unfriendly stickers have aggressive adhesives that can damage a helmet's shell.)
2. Help your child learn to use the buckle. Helmet straps may be difficult for young fingers. Help your child practice until he or she can buckle and release them easily.
3. Always insist your child wear the helmet when riding. Anyone can get hurt on a bike anywhere. Firm rules are usually needed for any safety practice.
4. Always insist your child remove the helmet when they arrive at a playground or climb trees. Helmets can snag in the equipment or on a tree limb and strangle the child.
5. When you ride together, wear your own helmet. Your own good example can make a big difference in encouraging your child to wear one.
6. Praise and reward your child each time. Your youngster
may feel strange at first wearing a helmet. You can take away some of the discomfort with words of support.
7. Begin the helmet habit with the first bicycle. Make it a firm rule and it will become a habit as your child grows, just like buckling up a seatbelt in the car.
7. Encourage other parents to buy helmets. Making helmets
normal is the best way to eliminate the discomfort of being "different."
Parents Tip #5: Playgrounds and Helmets Don't Mix!
In 1999 a Pennsylvania child strangled and died in a piece of non-standard playground equipment while wearing a bicycle
helmet. He was caught between two overlapping horizontal platforms when his helmet would not fit through the gap between them where his body had already gone. Here is more detail on
playground equipment problems. Trees have no standards for branch gaps, so don't let your child climb trees with a helmet on either, even though it may seem like a good idea!
All in all, today's bicycle helmets are inexpensive insurance
against the tragedy of serious head injury. They are lightweight, inexpensive, come in a wide variety of colors and designs, and provide good ventilation. Wearing a bicycle helmet makes good sense.
Check out this page on the disk if you need a simple explanation of how a helmet works.
3. Organizing a local bicycle helmet campaign
To promote bicycle helmet use, you need a plan. You must decide who to reach and how to do it. The following sections take you step-by-stop through this process. Along the way you will make important decisions shaping your campaign and fitting it to your community's needs and resources. The overview below gives
you a basic outline for designing a campaign. Look it over and
then browse through some of the ideas on the following pages.
This section is organized into the following topics.
- Select a target age group. Which age groups ride the most? Which age group is most at risk? Who wears helmets now? Who should be the campaign target?
- Set your project goals and objectives. Build campaign momentum. Raise awareness of bike injuries and head trauma. Increase helmet purchases through greater availability. Increase helmet use. Reduce the number and lessen the severity of head injuries.
- Using a steering committee. Build a coalition, hold successful meetings and involve your committee members.
There are few hard-and-fast rules on just how to do bicycle helmet promotion. Some people, for example, print discount coupons and distribute them in the schools, while others rely more on television and radio to spread the word. Some get local groups to donate money for helmets, while others go straight to the manufacturers for special discounts. Some put together coalitions of health-related groups, while others work alone or with one or two helpers. Some work only with the PTA. Some police departments have good success with bicycle rodeos. At least one local campaign involves organized religious groups.
Whichever approach you take, keep in mind that a good campaign
uses a variety of means to its end. A campaign that relies strictly on coupons or TV or school presentations will not have as much impact as a campaign that combines these elements.
As your campaign gains momentum, you'll find many opportunities
to get your message across. Take advantage of these opportunities
as they arise. Keep in mind, too, that changing people's attitudes on safety takes time. You may not achieve your goals in the first few months. But if you keep at it, you'll find success.
Select a target age group
One of your first decisions will be to choose a target group.
Ask yourself just who you want to reach. This is an important
decision because it affects many future choices including how
best to reach that audience. How do you decide? Ask yourself the
Which age groups ride the most?
In some communities, there is a large adult cycling population.
In others, elementary school kids are the only ones who ride. In still other areas kids are not allowed to ride much due to traffic and security concerns. Your bicycle shops, police or recreation departments may have some ideas. You may be able to find local bike use survey data. This is particularly true if the recreation department has gotten Federal Land and Water Conservation Fund grants from the State; recreational surveys are required.
If you don't have a survey, why not do one? Recruit a high school
or college class to do it for you. See the appendix for a sample
survey. If you can't afford the time or effort a survey requires,
start off by guessing what your biggest group will be. Your own
observations around town, coupled with those of other safety advocates, should give you a good start. Later, do the survey.
Which age group is most at risk?
Emergency room doctors and nurses can help with this question.
They see who comes in with bicycle-related injuries. Police data
may help too, but keep in mind that typically fewer than 20%
of all serious bike crashes are reported to the police. Use the
general categories listed below. As a start, statewide 10-14
year olds are the age group most at risk, according to a report
from the University of North Carolina. Studies consistently show that males are more at risk than females.
Who wears helmets now?
Before you set goals on increasing helmet use, you need to know
how many people (and of what age) wear them now. You can get this
information through a phone survey or by counting bicyclists at
several places around town. Pitt County, for example, conducted
a telephone survey during the early stages of their project to
determine how many kids wore helmets. North Carolina did a state-wide survey in 2001 and found only 17 per cent of their riders using helmets.
Bike counts can be very useful for several purposes and are a
good use of volunteer time. Pick count locations where you can
see a good assortment of bicyclists. A major bike route that passes near a school and a park but also serves adult commuters might be a good location. Count bikes from 7 AM to 7 PM on a weekday and the same period on a weekend. These records will be invaluable when it comes time for project evaluation, a key component of your helmet campaign. Here is an evaluation program designed in New York State so you don't have to reinvent that wheel.
Who should be the campaign target?
Once you have some ideas of who rides, who is most at risk, and
who wears helmets, you can decide which group is going to be the
first target for the campaign. Keep in mind that the target group may be best reached indirectly. For example, young kids may be best influenced through their parents or teachers.
Although there is a tendency to focus on age groups, there are other populations that are worthy of your consideration as our communities have become more diverse. Many urban helmet promoters have observed that helmet use is high in the affluent suburbs and low in the inner city, cutting across all age groups. Recent immigrants from countries where bicycle helmets are a novelty may be another target group in your area. Reaching such groups may require tailoring your program in a radically different way. At a minimum, you would probably want some Spanish language materials in many areas. It may also be desirable to work through ethnic groups or organized religious groups to reach particular immigrant populations. If you can pull at least one of these people into your campaign organization they can provide more ideas for the specific group that may never occur to you.
Get help from members of your target audience in choosing among
possible messages. Pick five to ten candidate messages and show
them to a number of people in the age group you want to reach. Ask them to tell you which make the most sense, which are confusing, which are convincing and which are weak. While you are at it, dig for info on where the messages might be most effective, and what kinds of promotion events your target age group might participate in.
Going through these questions may take some time. They require information, something you may not have at the start. But they will give you a sense of direction and provide information you can use in news releases and campaign literature.
You may change primary target audiences as your campaign progresses from year to year. And, while it's important to focus on a specific age group, try to produce some information for all ages. It's best not to give people the impression that only little kids, for example, need bicycle helmets.
Some tips on target age groups
Helmet campaigns from the U.S. and abroad have taught us the
following about the different possible target audiences. Most
campaigns have been directed at either kids or their parents.
Pre-school: Direct your messages mainly at parents and focus particularly on the importance of helmets for youngsters being carried in child carriers; these children are particularly vulnerable. Also discuss how adults should wear helmets themselves in order to be good role models for the kids.
E1ementary school: Again, direct messages mostly at parents. Focus on the importance of helmets for kids riding around the neighborhood. Emphasize that falls can cause serious head injuries and also mention that parents should be good role models. Some straight-forward messages directed at youngsters should help as well, particularly when delivered in school classes or assemblies.
Junior high school: One of the toughest potential audiences. Parental influence is less powerful and peer pressure, fashion, and one's personal image are more important than for younger students. Be careful of messages that adults think will be cool. Kids need straight talk from people who really know their stuff. Emergency Room doctors and expert cyclists--especially high-school aged cyclists--would be good.
High school: Another tough audience. Peer influence is
more powerful yet. Again, they need straight talk from experts,
preferably young ones. If helmet use becomes common only among the very young, expect older kids to balk at wearing them. Some laws require riders under 15 to wear helmets. When you turn 15 do you want to look 14?
College: Most campaigners have found it difficult to reach college-age adults. However, they are an important age group to consider, due to their influence over teen-age cyclists. General community campaigns (such as the Madison, Wisconsin, project mentioned in the appendix) may work and tend to focus on being a "well-dressed" cyclist--with a helmet. However, direct college student involvement should be better. Among collegiate club cyclists, requiring helmets on rides is a common approach. Serious safety messages may also work (e.g. in the campus newspaper). The Bicycle Helmet Safety Institute has found
that since virtually all college students have access to the Internet, putting up a page on the Web is an effective strategy for reaching them. If the page has enough factual content to provide easily accessible material for class papers, projects and speech class exercises, students will use it for research. Often this process puts the message before other students as papers are discussed or practice speeches are given in class. And if you educate a young person, they will be around a long time. So working with students of any age can be rewarding.
Middle age: This age group should be most likely to respond to logical arguments about the seriousness of head injuries. Virtually the same arguments that can be made for life insurance and seat belts should work for this group. They are generally still swayed more by fashion than by logic, but for them, fashion may include embracing a safety campaign that demonstrates their rationality and concern for their own or
their kids' welfare. Many parents now helmet their kids, but not themselves. They should be easy targets!
One PSA tried in the boating field shows a little boy wearing a life vest walking along a beach, while the voice-over talks about how the little boy is going out in the family boat with his parents. The boat is going to turn over. The happy thing is that the little boy has on a life vest, so he's going to be just fine... and then the parents come into the scene, without life vests, and the voice says "But he's going to lose his mother and father." There should be some way to adapt that theme. There are more PSA's on this disk.
Seniors: Very little has been done with this age
group. They have specialized publications and organizations who are generally eager for material that is seniors-oriented. All parts of the body age, generally getting more brittle and less flexible. So there may be special needs for seniors' helmets, a subject that is just beginning to be explored by researchers,
and on which we have no hard data. If the research indeed shows that seniors' brains age along with everything else, they may need helmets with less dense foam to accommodate a tendency to be injured at lower force levels than youngsters. The Consumer Reports article in 1994 did rate "softest landing" helmets, but the ones in 1997 and 2002 did not. For seniors, look for a helmet designed to protect against "mild" concussions, not just severe brain injuries. There are none on the market today that we are aware of.
Set your project goals and objectives
Once you know who your main target group is, and approximately
how many of them wear helmets, set some project goals and objectives. Your overall goal can be somewhat general, stating your project's main purpose. It could be, for example: To improve bicycle safety in the community. However, your objectives should be very specific.
The best objectives are measurable; you need to know when you
have reached your target. For example, if 2 percent of all cyclists in your target group wear bike helmets, one of your objectives might be to increase that number to 10 percent in one year.
By making sure that your objectives are measurable, you can avoid
one of the pitfalls of safety campaigns: setting vague objectives
and being unable to tell when--or if--they have been reached. Often, the people who run such campaigns must fall back on the old cliche that, "if it saves one life, it's worth it." The problem is that they have no way of knowing whether it has saved one life or done anything at all.
It's also important to set realistic objectives. A grandiose target may sound good until you fall far short. Then, it will hurt your future efforts to gather support.
Safe Kids USA offered these general objective categories for local helmet campaigns. The comments and specifics are ours.
1. Build campaign momentum.
One local study showed that bicyclists were not against helmets...few had thought about wearing them. This may be true in your community, too. When you begin your campaign, expect to meet lack of awareness and apathy. But if you start with a dedicated core group, you can build a campaign that can change things over time. Here's a possible objective regarding campaign momentum:
In one year, we will have a core group of ten key volunteers
and the cooperation and backing of the local PTA, the medical
groups, the police, the media, and key youth groups.
2. Raise awareness of bike injuries and head trauma.
One reason few people think about helmets is that few know the
facts about head and brain injuries. As they learn how vulnerable
they and their kids may be, bicycle helmet use will begin to make
more sense. Here's a possible objective regarding awareness of
In one year, a survey will show that 30 percent of the local residents know the basic facts about bike head trauma associated with bicycle crashes.
3. Increase helmet purchases through greater availability.
If few people want helmets, few will buy them. And bike sellers
will not push items they can't sell. As you increase awareness,
work to make sure helmets are available through bike shops and
mass merchandisers. Here's a possible objective regarding helmet
In one year, local merchandisers will report a 50 percent increase in helmet sales.
4. Increase helmet use.
The purpose of all the effort is to increase helmet use, not just
awareness or sales. If people buy helmets but leave them at home,
that's not solving the problem. Therefore, it's important to measure use. Here's a possible objective regarding increased helmet use:
In one year, bicycle helmet use among our target audience will
increase by 50 percent, as measured in on-road bike counts.
5. Improve helmet fit.
One of today's most serious helmet problems is that riders--kids in particular--are using helmets that have not been adjusted to fit them. If the helmet is skewed when you hit, there may be zero helmet between you and the pavement. That's not a pleasant thought. And the 1997 Harborview research shows that there is a significant problem with injuries to helmeted riders that the authors attributed to improper fit. A possible objective:
In one year field observations will show that more than 50 per cent of riders have helmets that fit well.
6. Reduce the number of bike injuries, especially head injuries and lessen the severity of head injuries.
While this is the real bottom line, it will be
difficult to measure, especially in the early years of your project. But take heart! In the State of Victoria, Australia, as the helmet campaign grew, serious head injuries at hospitals fell by 30 percent.
It may be possible for your local hospitals to become involved and to report their head injury statistics. Here's a possible objective regarding bike injuries: In five years, emergency room admissions for bicycling head injuries will decrease by 30 percent.
Having clear goals and objectives will also help when you look for support. Donors are more likely to back your cause if you can demonstrate that you know both where you are going and how to get there.
Sample goal statements from North Carolina helmet campaigns
Here are goals and objectives from two campaigns submitted
for funding to the North Carolina Division of Maternal and Child
Health, Office for Prevention. Look them over and decide which
objectives are most easily measurable, which are least measurable, and which would be useful in your campaign.
Goal: To have fewer bicycle-related head injuries
1. By the end of the project, to increase by 30 percent parents' knowledge about bicycle-related injuries, bicycle safety, and helmet use;
2. By the end of the project to increase by 20 percent the number of children, ages 5-10, using helmets;
3. By the end of the project, to increase by 30 percent the availability of bicycle helmets; and
4. To display helmets and bicycle safety materials at a minimum of five community sites.
Goal: To promote the use of bicycle and skateboard helmets.
1. To make parents and the general public aware of the need
for bicycle and skateboard helmet use.
2. To involve other agencies and civic organizations in an
effort to assure the continuation of this project.
3. To significantly increase the use of bicycle and skateboard
helmets (especially for children age 5-15).
4. To make effective low-cost helmets available through the
provision of discount coupons.
Using a steering committee
Building a coalition
A successful large campaign requires the cooperation of many people. By forming a bicycle helmet campaign committee of five to ten members, you can assemble a core group to solicit donations, promote the project, find volunteers, and solve problems. An effective committee will work to assure a future for your campaign.
Select potential members carefully. In an important sense, your committee should be a coalition of people concerned with safety and you should recruit from a variety of sources. As a suggestion, consider active people from medicine; the local bike club; bike shops; the media; civic clubs; youth organizations; parent/teacher groups; the local health, fire, and police departments; safety organizations; and the local office of the AAA.
Keep your committee to a workable size; five to ten members is
a good range. Having too many members can slow progress to a crawl. But having too few members will result in volunteer burnout, a situation in which your core group dissolves from
Holding successful meetings
Set your meeting dates well in advance, and plan on follow-up
emails or phone calls to remind members of meeting times and locations. Work to make it easy and enjoyable for them to attend; and make sure they know their efforts are appreciated. With a committee of busy people, you may find it difficult to get everyone together at one time. Why not try regular breakfast meetings at a local cafe?
Keep your meetings brief and to the point. Always work from a
well-developed agenda, emailed in advance.
Involving committee members
Email a brief progress report to members regularly. This will help them keep on top of things and feel a part of the project. It will also help keep your meetings short, since committee members will already have received the materials. If a committee member has no email, just print out the email message and mail it on paper!
Key Committee Members
Publicity: The person in charge of publicity should have
a good feel for dealing with the press. If possible, pick someone
who has a track record (including news clippings). They will
put out all news releases and schedule appearances on TV and radio shows.
Sponsorships and donations: Securing money, goods, and
services takes a special talent and the willingness to ask. Having key contacts in the community is important as well. Remember that in-kind donations such as printing services, design work, and helmets for prizes can be as valuable as money.
Volunteers: Your volunteer coordinator must be able to
make the work look attractive and valuable to potential volunteers and should have contacts in service organizations and other groups. Further, they must know how to treat volunteers once they are recruited. A good coordinator can help keep volunteers active for years by giving them well-defined tasks and making sure they feel appreciated.
Programs: Once your project starts getting publicity, you
will get requests for presentations. (But don't wait for the requests to come--solicit invitations to speak to various groups!) You need someone who can prepare a presentation, speak in front of a group, and find other speakers. They must prepare scripts or Powerpoint presentations for use by others.
Production: Getting materials produced takes a basic knowledge of computer graphics and word processing. While your materials need not be fancy (unless you plan a large printing budget), they should look good and make sense. Some materials can be purchased outright, or campaigns and organizations such as the Bicycle Helmet Safety Institute are willing to let you reprint their materials free for any non-profit use (see listings below). Most campaigns use copying donated on office photocopy machines. We have some info on this disk if you need materials in Spanish.
To make your progress report an easier task, use a PC database to produce labels or envelopes. Then you can prepare a one-page newsletter, make copies or print them, fold, staple, and label them, and get them into the mail in less than half an hour.
Don't underestimate the value of a regular update mailing. Half
an hour of keyboarding every two weeks can pay off handsomely in increased participation and enthusiasm by your committee.
Delegation of tasks is another key to an interested committee and a successful campaign. Make specific assignments with realistic
completion dates. Your committee serves you best when each member
can take on an important and well-defined task, such as one of the duties outlined above.
4. Creating your campaign
This section is organized into the following topics:
- Choosing a time frame, deciding how long the campaign will run, setting a timetable, finding funding and supplies, recognizing volunteers and sponsors, evaluating your results and planning future campaigns.
- Choosing campaign messages - - Your basic message and support messages.
- Assembling the pieces of a campaign - - Creating displays, offering rewards for helmet use, cutting helmet prices, making direct contacts, using the media, developing your publicity tools and distributing helmet promotion materials.
If that sounds hard, check out how one community, Monroe County NY, has done it. They have an annual Wheel Sport Safety Awareness Contest. They provide a description of the contest and all the forms and documents they use, from a kindergarten coloring page to the form for a sixth grade essay, rap song or poem.
Choosing a time-frame
Two excellent times for the primary campaign effort are early
spring, when people are starting to think about bicycling, and
fall, when students go back to school. Many helmet projects focus
on these times.
But you don't have to limit your projects to these two seasons.
The weeks before Christmas would be a good time for promoting helmets as presents. Mid-winter would be fine for a poster contest. Mid-summer would be a time to hand out prizes to cyclists seen riding with helmets, and is a popular time for police department bike rodeos because there are no school activities to interfere. Take advantage of each season's opportunities.
Deciding how long it will run
While your overall campaign can run for years and get better with
the passing time, it's best to have a specific period for each
year's main push. In order to accommodate a variety of activities, consider a time period of at least one week, but no more than a month. For example, if you plan to use discount coupons, give them an expiration date. This does two things: It makes retailers more likely to cooperate, since they know how long they will have to honor the discounts. And it improves response; in advertising, deadlines are well known for their ability to increase response because they force people to make a decision.
Setting the timetable
Establish a detailed timetable for your project, showing what
needs to be done when, who is in charge, and who will help. By
identifying each step, you can see which can become bottlenecks
if not handled on time. For example, if you plan to give out helmet stickers, find out how much lead time your printer needs. Look over the sample time table shown below. While it isn't very detailed, it should give you a sense for how to create one for
Finding money and supplies
Your next stop is to set a budget and start going after donations. You will probably buy some supplies and services, but in-kind contributions can provide for the bulk of your needs. List proposed cash purchases separately from expected donations. (See below for sample budgets.)
You may want one sponsor for your effort, or you may wish to attract several co-sponsors. By securing several sponsors, you reduce the amount required of each and you broaden the support base for your project.
Possible co-sponsors include recreation departments, police associations, the AAA chapter, bicycle shops, service clubs, medical groups, and insurance companies. But there is probably no more powerful sponsor than the local media: TV, radio or newspaper. Having a media sponsor ensures more coverage for your campaign than any other technique.
Most contributions will not come from your co-sponsor, but from many small donors. As examples, ask a local printer to print your brochures or a bike shop to contribute helmets for demonstrations. Many businesses are willing to donate photocopying.
Tracking down donations is a good task to delegate, but find someone who knows how to ask. Some people get easily embarrassed, hem and haw, and end up asking for "any contributions you could spare." Others mean well but are paralyzed at the thought of actually asking in person or on the phone. Occasionally you can find a person who is happy to solicit donations for your cause, and those people are valuable volunteers.
If you need two helmets, ask for them. Don't leave your prospective donor guessing. People are more likely to agree to specific requests than to vague (and possibly unlimited) ones. You may be surprised how easy it is to get those helmets!
Remind helpers that they aren't begging for donations, but are
giving merchants an opportunity to participate in an important
safety campaign. They should bring materials to show donors what
the project is about and what they will gain from being associated with it.
Talk to potential donors early. Three weeks notice may be enough when asking for photocopying, but go after your major needs well in advance. For example, a local bicycle shop may be able to set aside some of last year's helmets for you IF you ask soon enough. If you want state or local foundation funding, find out what the funding cycle is. You often have to submit a grant proposal six months to a year in advance.
If you are running a more involved campaign, the Bikes 4 Kids program in Utah raised funding in 2006 for 1,000 bicycles, helmets, t-shirts and locks through sponsorships, a fundraising dinner with silent auction and bicycle rides, including a celebrity ride with Salt Lake City native Dave Zabriskie, the third American ever to wear the yellow jersey in the Tour de France. Some major charities use annual bike rides to raise funds, asking each participant to bring donations in. Adding a local celebrity can make it easier to recruit riders. The silent auction has proven successful for some local bike clubs, and in the case of the Washington Area Bicyclist Association has been combined with a cocktail party with formal wear in elegant surroundings to bring in an older and well-heeled group of donors.
Finally, be creative and resourceful. Remember, there is more than one source for everything you need and there are many ways to get what you want.
Task: Month: 1 2 3 4 5
Get background information X
Assemble core group X
Design campaign X X X
Set budget X X
Contact PTAs X
Meet with various groups X X X X
Raise money for campaign X X X X X
Buy videos X
Assemble press kits/fact sheets X
Contact bike dealers X
Contact TV, radio, newspapers X
Get TV spots X
Print discount coupons X
Distribute coupons in schools X
Contact bike dealers re: results X
Compile results X
Design next year's campaign X X
Recognizing volunteers and sponsors
It's a good idea to get your steering committee and other volunteers special t-shirts, pins, or caps. Such items will help identify them to the public, and will further add to their feeling of being involved.
You might plan a banquet or a special breakfast. And don't forget
the "thank you" notes after they do a great job on a key task.
As often as possible acknowledge co-sponsors and each contributor
in your printed literature or on your Web page. During public events, mention sponsors and contributors over a public-address system. But strike a balance. If you go overboard, people may think your project is simply an advertisement.
Evaluating the results
If you've planned your campaign well, evaluating the results will
be rewarding, useful, and relatively easy. By setting achievable,
measurable goals, you will be able to tell if you've accomplished
what you set out to do. Reaching your first year's goals can be
a great boost for your second year. It can also give you plenty
of useful information for news releases and fine-tuning your approach. Expect to make mistakes but learn from each one
Planning future campaigns
Your evaluation should give you a good idea of where you want
to go next year and the year after. Start thinking about it immediately. Revise your goals and objectives. Then do some loosely-structured brainstorming sessions. Throw around ideas, regardless of how crazy they may initially seem. After you have plenty of ideas, refine the list into ones that you can accomplish and that meet your goals. Then, start planning your second year!
Choosing campaign messages
Your basic message
Your basic message should be, as stated by Safe Kids USA: "Wear a helmet every time you ride a bike."
This simple, clear-cut statement needs the support of detailed
arguments about why one should wear a helmet. The first part of
this manual should supply most of those arguments, while the references listed below and the suggestions given here will help to supply the rest.
In promoting this basic idea, keep in mind a famous rule of advertising: your message must ring true for your target audience. Even if your message seems true to you, if your target audience says "That's a lie!" you've lost whatever credibility you may have had.
Some helmet campaigns have used true statements that didn't seem true; and they lost their audiences. Others used statements that were closer to wishful thinking than truth ("Helmets look cool!" or "Everyone's wearing one!") and they lost their audiences too.
Barry Elliott, consultant to the best Australian helmet campaigns, says that "Successful communicators begin with a thorough understanding of the viewpoint of the audience. It is critical to know what can't be changed and what can be built upon,if we are going to encourage people to wear bicycle helmets."
An excellent way to decide among messages is to show them to a group of people in your intended target audience. Ask them which messages seem best, which not so good. Also you might ask them to come up with ideas of their own. This is your Focus Group, and they can be invaluable for checking changes and additions as the campaign progresses.
As you consider messages for your campaign, you should bear in mind that for most riders, a helmet is a piece of wearing apparel more than it is a safety device. It may be almost impossible to convince many riders that they will crash, but you can bet that a large percentage of them will be concerned with the way they look in a helmet. This applies to normal riders, not just vain people. Fashion sells more helmets than safety. You are a safety advocate, so you may not find that admirable or intuitive, but you can still use it to put together a successful campaign. The theme you are looking for should still have
safety content, but if you are going to make use of the proven results from Madison Avenue you should also make the point that helmets make the rider look more competent, more intelligent, more thoughtful, more experienced on a bicycle, cooler and somehow much more attractive to the opposite gender!
Aside from your main message or slogan, you should have supporting statements that round out your campaign's theme. These can deal with a number of important side issues, like the following:
- Looks and comfort:
- The new helmets are light, cool, colorful and comfortable
- Helmets make you look more competent, smarter and cooler
- Helmet prices have come down, down, down
- Helmets are less expensive than hospital care
- Helmets cost less than a pair of sneakers
- Helmets can last four or five years if they aren't crashed
- About 800 bicyclists die in crashes in the U.S. each year
- About 680 deaths could have been prevented by helmets last year
- Nearly 75% of all cycling deaths are due to head injuries
Here is a sample outline for a helmet talk to school kids or other groups. It is easy to adapt to different age groups.
Popular helmet campaign messages
Here are some messages used in various early helmet
campaigns. In today's environment most of them seem to lack something: that spark that really catches your attention and provokes action. Some are certainly better than others but all of them can give you ideas. Some are also taken from commercial
products. Rather than copying them, use these messages to spark your own creative process and develop something that seems less like old 20th century stuff. When you hit on a better one, send it to us
to put in this list for the next reader!
"Are you cool enough to wear a helmet?"
"Use your head...use a helmet."
"Don't knock yourself out on a bicycle. Get a bike helmet
"O.S. Cat says...Wear a helmet every time you ride a bike!
He is One Smart Cat!"
"Helmets are for cyclists who think for themselves...and
want to go on thinking."
"Protection: you're not born with it. Wear your bicycle helmet"
"Protect your head - Wear a helmet!"
"Keep your brains where they belong: In your head!"
"Get the hard-head safety habit. Smart kids wear bike helmets."
"I don't want you to end up like me, please wear a helmet."
(boy in wheel chair)
"Don't be a street stain. Wear your helmet."
"Wear a helmet....it won't kill you!"
"Your head is not as hard as you think it is."
"Your child's head is not as hard as you think it is."
"Protect your child with a bike helmet."
"Parents are Precious Too - Wear a Helmet"
"Dear Parent...Do your kids need bicycle helmets?"
"Be bike smart. The child in your life depends on you for
a lifetime of health."
"Heads you win."
"Do your kids need a bicycle helmet?"
"Protect your child from head injury."
"Friends don't let friends ride ignorant!"
"Keep your head in a safe place...wear a helmet."
"Be a well-dressed cyclist - wear a helmet."
"Bike helmets: the smart choice."
"No helmet, no brains!"
"Get your head into a bike helmet."
"Get into the helmet habit."
"Buy a helmet - and wear it!"
"It never hurts to be in style. Get your head into a bike
"Bike helmets make safety sense."
"Bike helmets: the smart choice."
"Bicycle helmets: For your head's sake...show your good sense...buy
and wear a helmet today!"
"Bicycle helmets: Do you use your head?"
"Protect your head. Where would you be without it?"
"Bike helmets - Don't hit the road without one."
"Bike helmets make sense."
"If we could predict when accidents are going to happen, there wouldn't be any!"
Public Service Announcements
These come from Valodi Foster, of the California Department of Health Services.
So your teen won't wear a bike helmet? Remind him or her that wearing a helmet correctly every time is responsible behavior...the same kind needed to drive the family car at 16.
So your child won't wear a bicycle helmet? Remind him or her that wearing a helmet correctly every time is responsible behavior...the same kind needed to earn that new privilege he has been asking for.
It's a fact. Approximately 900 people, including more than 200 children, are killed annually in bicycle related incidents nationwide, and about 60 percent of these deaths involve a head injury. The good news: (pause) research indicates that a helmet can reduce the risk of head and brain injury by 63 to 88 percent. Use your head. Use a helmet.
A message brought to you by (name of local organization).
15-20 Second Spot
So you've heard that 60 percent of all bicycle deaths involve a head injury, and now you want to buy a helmet. The problem is, you don't know what kind of helmet to buy. As of March 1999, all helmets are required to meet a standard set by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission that ensures adequate protection of the head. Now you know. So what are you waiting for? Get your helmet today!
A message brought to you by (name of local organization).
15-20 Second Spot
You've bought the helmet for your kids, and now it's time to enjoy the beautiful weather and start riding those bikes! But your child won't wear the helmet. So ride with your kids and wear your helmet too! Kids tend to model what their parents do. So if you want your children to practice good bicycle safety, make sure you practice what you teach!
A message brought to you by (name of local organization).
30 Second Spot
Hi, I'm Officer [NAME] of the [STATE/LOCAL] police department. Too often I've seen the tragedy of children seriously injured or killed in bicycle crashes simply because they weren't wearing a bicycle helmet. I've seen the devastating effect it has on families and on the community. We can prevent these senseless deaths. That's why law enforcement across [STATE/CITY] are
out, right now, enforcing [STATE's] bicycle helmet laws. No warnings. No excuses. So do your job, or I'll do mine. Make sure your children wear their helmet each and every time they ride their bikes. There's just too much to lose.
A message brought to you by (name of local organization).
30 Second Spot
Hi, I'm Officer [NAME] of the [STATE/LOCAL] police department with a safety tip we can all live with. It's simple...make sure your children wear their bicycle helmets. Every year I see too many children seriously injured or killed in bicycle crashes. In fact, bicycle crashes are the leading cause of death and injuries among children 5-14. I'm working hard to prevent these senseless deaths...but I need your help. There's just too much to lose.
A message brought to you by (name of local organization)
30 Second Spot
What protects children, saves lives and saves taxpayers millions? Wearing a bicycle helmet. In fact, if every child in [STATE] just put on a bicycle helmet, we would save the lives of more than [XXX] children next year alone. Plus it would save taxpayers [$XX] in health care and insurance costs. So make sure your children wear their helmets and support stronger enforcement
of [STATE'S] bicycle helmet law. There's just too much to lose.
A message brought to you by (name of local organization)
A Longer Dialogue
"Just in Case"
Mark: Hey Joe, let's ride our bikes and go get some baseball cards.
Joe: Okay, let me go home to get my bike.
Mark: You don't have to go all the way home, just use my brother's bike. He won't mind.
Joe: Even if I did use your brother's bike, I'd still have to go home and
get my helmet.
Mark: (Laughing as he starts to tease Joe) Helmet? Aw c'mon. Those things are for little kids. You can ride a bike just fine. You don't need a helmet. Let's just go.
Joe: Sorry, Mark, can't. What if something weird happens. I'd rather be safe than sorry.
Mark: You make it sound like riding a bike is dangerous.
Joe: A report I had to do for school made me think about it. In (name of
state) (xxx amount) of people have been really hurt and that (xxx amount) of
people have been killed in bike crashes. Even if you do survive a crash, a
serious injury can lead to permanent problems. I know I don't want to end up
having my mom helping me every time I have to do simple things, like eating
or using the bathroom. I don't know about you, man, but I'd rather wear the
helmet just in case.
Mark: Well. . . . .okay. . . .. .you go do what you have to do. When
you're ready, come get me in my room.
Joe: In your room? I thought we're riding to the card store? Why don't we
meet at the corner like we usually do?
Mark: Because it's gonna take me at least 15 minutes to find my helmet in
Joe: (Laughing) Oh, okay. I'll be back in 15 minutes.
Narrator: Use your head. Use a helmet. After all, it's your head.
Valodi Foster, MPH
A PSA Available on the Internet
If you connect to the Brain Injury Association of Minnesota Web site at www.braininjurymn.org/Media/bully.htm you will find a full-blown PSA in .mpg file format. It's a big file (9 megs), with sound and picture ready to go. For info on using the .mpg, please use the contact info on the site.
The PSA shows a kid riding along a neighborhood street when a bully rides alongside, harassing him about his sissy helmet. As they ride, the bully is not paying attention to where he is going, and he suddenly collides with a board sticking out the back of a truck parked in a driveway, ending the PSA. It is quite a shock, and most people will never figure out that the bully got hit in the face with the board, and a normal bike helmet would not have protected his face anyway.
5. The pieces of a campaign
The most effective helmet campaigns combine a number of important elements. It has been said that a campaign that uses only one approach will probably fail. Consider the following when putting together your package and keep your target group firmly in mind.
Try to put your message where many people gather or pass by.
Create a list of as many of those places as you can. Here are
Many businesses allow groups to use their windows for public service messages. The problem, initially, will be to find enough materials to make the displays look interesting. One approach would be to start with a helmet poster contest and use the entries in your displays.
In commercial strip-type areas, many businesses will allow use of their changeable signs for public service messages. Keep the message simple (use your campaign slogan) and you may get it up
all over town!
Several communities have used large billboards to get across bicycle safety messages. The helmet campaign in Pitt County, North Carolina, for example, used one to promote helmet use among kids.
Another community, Cranford, New Jersey, hung a large banner from
an overpass that spanned one of the busiest roads in town. Nearly
everyone got the message.
If you have a talented designer or carpenter, consider building
a standalone display that can be moved around to different schools, the malls, medical centers, and public buildings. While flat vertical surfaces that hold posters are about the easiest to put together, other displays might be more interesting for the viewers. Here are a few things you might incorporate into a display:
- Broken helmets with the owners' crash stories
- X-rays of skull fractures
- Posters showing well-known people wearing helmets
- Colorful helmets that people can try on for a look in
a mirror (hook the helmets to the display with a small cable)
- Student helmet posters
Places for displays:
- Doctors' offices
- Dentists' offices
- Health Clinics
- Health clubs
- Convenience stores
- Department store bike sections
- Video arcades
- Baseball card stores
- Fast food shops
- Bike shops
- Computer game stores
- Magazine and book shops
- Bank lobbies
- Insurance offices
- Downtown shop window displays
- Record stores
- School lobbies
- Campus cafeterias
- City and county offices
- Park bulletin beards
- Police departments
- Fire departments
- Swimming pool bulletin beards
- Busy plazas (especially covered ones)
Rewards for helmet use
Another popular way to promote bicycle helmets is to reward
those who currently wear them. Often, these cyclists get teased
by friends who don't wear helmets; this is especially true of
young riders. Here are some ideas that have been used around the
Prizes for Schools
In one campaign, elementary schools were given blank posters on
which to paste pictures of students who wore helmets. The schools with the largest proportions of helmeted bicyclists won prizes, as did the students. Helmets are a natural part of any "ride your bike to school day," of course, fitting in well with campaigns to reduce obeisity. Another idea for emphasizing bright clothing is a day to award "Best and Brightest" prizes to those with the brightest clothing and helmets.
Coupons for wearers
During one city's campaign, cycling superheroes Sprocketman
and Sally Streetwise patrolled the street rewarding bicyclists
for wearing their helmets. Cyclists received their choice of movie tickets, video game tokens, or ice cream gift certificates. Local merchants donated the prizes and members of the bicycle club performed the superhero roles.
Cutting helmet prices
Even though helmet prices in discount stores are low, there is little doubt that cutting the prices of bicycle helmets can boost sales. Parents may be hard-pressed to buy helmets for their entire family. Prices may not have fallen as much in less competitive markets. And, of course, everyone loves a bargain, which can motivate a purchase far beyond the actual money saved.
There are a number of possible approaches.
You can distribute discount coupons in several ways. One is the
approach used in Missoula, Montana (see the Case Study in Appendix 6H below). They got all the local bike shops to offer discounts on helmets and printed the prices on coupons distributed through the schools. Shop owners were asked to keep the redeemed coupons and turn them in at the end of the three-week Spring campaign. Counting redeemed coupons told campaign officials how many helmets were sold.
Further, Missoula used the names from the coupons for a follow-up survey six months later. The discounts came out of the dealers' profits; however, since campaign planning started the previous fall, shop owners were able to secure good prices on the helmets they discounted. Since that campaign, prices have fallen to the point where dealers can now find good quality helmets for dealer prices of under $10 each. Even at normal bike shop markups, that should yield a final price to the consumer of about $15. Although this may be more than your local discount store, and more than you can arrange through a direct buy campaign, the help offered by good shops in fitting the helmets they sell can make the difference worthwhile.
Another approach with discount coupons is the one used in Madison, Wisconsin. They published the coupons in local newspapers and customers could buy helmets at discount prices at the shops listed. In this case, the shops also bore the cost of the discounts. On a smaller scale, a Pennsylvania bicycle club put several hundred dollars towards $5.00 discounts on helmets bought at a local bike shop.
The State of Oregon, in participation with helmet manufacturers
and retailers, offered helmet discount coupons to youngsters who created helmet posters at mall-based activities around the state.
A December holiday season discount coupon published in local newspapers can motivate grandparents and others to give helmets as holiday gifts.
Low retail prices
Simply reducing retail prices on helmets for a specific period
of time is another possible approach. In one campaign, organizers were able to convince a large, locally-based company to underwrite low prices on helmets for sale at various bike shops. In another, the bike shops themselves were able to offer low prices through discounts from the manufacturers and reduced profit margins. At today's prices this approach has become more practical.
Several successful campaigns have included bulk helmet purchases, generally organized through the schools. These usually involve a direct link between campaign organizers and a helmet manufacturer. For example, the late Bette Coan of Palo Alto, California, worked with Bell Helmets in her school-based campaign (See Appendix 6-F). She bought directly from the factory; quantities were based on orders taken at the schools. In this way, she sold thousands of helmets to kids, parents, and families and became known as the Helmet Lady of Palo Alto. Since then, more manufacturers have entered the direct sales market, and several organizations now offer direct sales campaigns. Select this link for a current listing of sources of low-cost helmets for promotion campaigns.
In recent years several Safe Kids campaigns around the country have purchased helmets for donation to needy kids. They got local merchants and civic clubs to supply the money and bike shops offered discounts. Safe Kids mounted a big national campaign in 1989 and a second campaign in 2002. With their tie-in to Bell Helmets, they have been able to distribute thousands of free helmets and sell thousands more to their own chapters and other organizations at less than $10 each.
In the years since those campaigns, a number of local programs have worked with donations from Lion's Clubs, Jaycees, local bicycle clubs and many other local service organizations, including the Elks, Kiwanis, Shriners, Knights of Columbus and Veterans of Foreign Wars. Although these programs have not attracted the attention given to large national campaigns, local organizations are often sympathetic to the need to promote bicycle helmets and are good sources for the modest amounts needed to fund a local campaign. Helmets meeting our national CPSC safety standard are available from the sources listed in our cheap helmets page starting at about $5 each.
One very successful campaign in Australia featured large newspaper ads, carrying the State of Victoria's helmet rebate coupons. When people bought bicycle helmets, they could send in the coupons, with proof of purchase, for a $10.00 rebate. During one Christmas season, the State redeemed several hundred thousand dollars worth of rebate coupons! At the time, helmet prices were high in the Australian market.
One helmet campaign in the Western U.S. featured a drawing for ten bicycle helmets (donated by helmet manufacturers). Participants filled out their tickets at local bike shops, stating their helmet preference, and the drawing was held at city hall. Over 300 people registered for the drawing during the two week promotion.
Wear your helmet to lunch day
Fast food restaurants in your community may agree to provide a treat or small discount to anyone bringing in a bike helmet to lunch.
Wake up and wear a helmet day
Local coffee shops may agree to provide a second shot of coffee or a discount to helmet-wearers.
Making direct contacts
Getting out into the community is a critical part of any helmet
campaign. Simply producing pamphlets and TV spots won't have the
impact that personal appearances will. At first, one or two volunteers may have to do most of the appearances. But it helps to work towards the day you will have a speaker's bureau, with three to five people to handle the task. This can prevent volunteer burnout, which could result if one person handles all programs. For this reason, put together a standard script (in at least outline form) and a list of speakers of various ages who can help get your message across to a variety of audiences.
Assemble several standard kits for the speaker to take. For kids,
this might include Sprocketman brochures, helmet flyers, and pamphlets for parents. For civic groups, this might include pamphlets for parents and helmet flyers.
Groups to consider
Here are some of the groups you will need to reach, along with
ideas on how to do it. Be creative in coming up with your presentations, however. And keep in mind that someone who is excited about a subject will do a much better job of presenting than someone who is bored.
Classes and youth groups: Presenting safety ideas to kids can be a challenge. Very young children seem to accept what authority figures say with little questioning. However, once they get to fourth or fifth grade, the job of convincing them gets tough. Two things will help.
First, all ages tend to respect knowledge and skill. If you can find a talented and well-spoken cyclist to give presentations, the chances are the kids will listen. If you can find a doctor to
talk about head injuries or a police officer or emergency medical technician to talk about crashes they have seen, that will be good too.
Second, they look up to kids a bit older than they are. For example, if you want to present helmet information to junior high school kids, find an articulate high school student. If he or she happens to be a good cyclist, that's a perfect combination.
Parent/teacher groups: PTAs usually welcome presentations
concerning child safety. Here again, credibility is important,
although in a different way. Unlike kids, parents don't care as
much if your presenter is a skilled cyclist, although it won't
hurt. Doctors, nurses, and police officers make especially good
speakers for this audience. Keep the presentation short and well edited, since most PTA programs have plenty to cover.
Community groups: Sometimes, community groups ask for speakers simply because they want to fill a slot in their meeting. Usually they do not know much about the need for bicycle helmets and already have other projects to support. But a positive attitude may convert them to helmet advocacy, and you may be able to recruit some of them for your cause. If your presentation is convincing, you may get their help (although it may not come immediately). This is especially true if your project has a track record in getting local publicity. People in community groups, like most others, enjoy being associated with important causes and winners.
Health care centers: Doctors offices, clinics, and hospitals are good places to promote bicycle helmets. Encourage physicians to talk to their patients about the threat of head injury. Pediatricians should be particularly helpful and the American Academy of Pediatrics is part of the national HeadSmart Campaign, which promotes bicycle helmets.
Suggested outline for a PTA presentation
2. Bicycle safety overview:
- Who you are and where you're from
- Why you're here
3. Head injuries: long term trauma
- Bicycle safety and crashes
- Head injuries
- Local information (if available)
4. The benefits of wearing helmets:
- Head injuries aren't like broken arms
- Long-term care requirements
- The rehabilitation process
- Helmets prevent 63 to 88 percent of deaths and serious brain injuries
- Head injuries are responsible for 75 percent of cyclists' deaths.
5. What today's helmets are about:
- Protection (standards)
- Looks and fashion
- How to fit a helmet
- Costs vs. benefits
6. What your campaign is about:
- Your goals and objectives
- Your organization (if you have one)
- Your schedule and projects
7. How the audience can help:
- How they can get involved
- Where their school can fit in
- Buying helmets for children
- Wearing helmets themselves
- Telling others about the value of helmets
- Helping distribute literature
Bike Safety Talk
We have on this disk an outline for a bike safety talk for kids. It can also be adapted for adults, of course.
Sometimes a physical demonstration can do more to drive home your point than all the talking in the world! Many helmet demos involve eggs or other breakables. In fact, one organization makes an "egg helmet" for just that purpose. There are a jillion creative ways to drop and egg with or without protection, and kids love to see something break. Here are two demos using melons, jello and light bulbs:
- Hal Fenner's Melon Drop - You need a not-too-ripe honeydew melon. Pumpkins can be better, but finding head-sized ones is difficult. Take your helmets to the grocery to find the right size honeydew. Shaking the melon tells you which is ripe--you can hear the seeds rattle in a ripe honeydew, so avoid the noisy ones. Draw smiley faces, or one smiley and one pffffft face on the melons. Put one melon in a helmet. Hold the helmeted and unhelmeted melons out to your sides, one in each hand, and tip your hands toward the audience to drop them in unison. The unhelmeted honeydew will smash. Whee. The helmet on the other melon will typically last for three drops, then the helmet will
split on the fourth one, still preventing the melon from smashing. The helmet must be destroyed, and never used for anything again! Some of its foam will be crushed where
- Dane Luhrsen's Light bulb Drop - Wrap a light bulb in heavy duty kitchen plastic wrap. Secure the bottom with a rubber band. Tape the wrapped bulb into a bicycle helmet. Drop the helmet top down from above your head onto a hard, flat surface. The light bulb will not break. Now drop the light bulb without the helmet. The bulb will shatter. Do not use this helmet again for riding, although with only a light bulb inside it should last indefinitely for more demos. Be sure it is marked "demo only - not for riding."
- The Jello Brain - Only your imagination limits you in the use of the famous Jello brain mold, a mold that you fill with gray or pink Jello or another gelatin product to make a model of the brain. You can order one from one of the companies on our gelatin mold page.
Getting media support
People often complain that their event or project wasn't covered by the newspaper, radio, or television. They feel they've been slighted or ignored while other, less worthy events got lots of coverage.
Publicity doesn't just happen. Reporters and film crews don't
roam the streets looking for stories about community groups. Nor do they know what's going on everywhere in town.
Tell them what you're doing and why it's worth covering. Even
if you do this, you won't get all the publicity you want. But
you will get some, particularly as your project matures and gains credibility. This is where having a media sponsor for your program pays big dividends.
Developing your publicity tools
The press kit: As you promote your project, assemble a
press kit. The kit should contain news releases, fact sheets,
story ideas and photographs. Send it to all local media when
you start and send one to any new reporter who contacts you.
News releases: Your releases should clearly and concisely
tell the who, what, where, when, why of your project. As the campaign gains momentum, put out releases when you reach
important milestones (See the list below).
As time passes, refine your news release list, adding names as
you learn them. Keep the list current; reporters change jobs frequently.
Fact sheets: Put together one-page and two-page fact sheets that describe the importance of helmets, the seriousness of head injuries, the make-up of your group, and its achievements and plans. These will help reporters come up to speed on the topic quickly.
Story ideas: Put together story ideas for the local media.
For example, if head injury victims or their families are willing, have them talk about their experiences. The Seattle campaign uses this approach to make the public aware of the threat of brain injury. True stories of real people are much more convincing than statistics or theories. With the cooperation of local emergency room physicians, you can get dramatic stories to share.
Also, look for people whose helmets saved them from head injury.
Ask the bike shops to help; often, when someone buys a replacement helmet, they will mention their crash. And encourage people to come forward.
The media often feel that celebrities and politicians are newsworthy. You can attract media attention with a trail safety photo op if you have the mayor there, for example. Add local athletes, police on bikes, an emergency room physician and anyone who is a household name in your community and you are almost guaranteed some coverage.
Possible topics for news releases
The project begins: What it's all about; why helmets are
important; what you hope to achieve.
Local accident study data: In conjunction with local police and medical centers, you release results of a local accident study.
The project gains key support: You secure important sponsorships and help from the community.
The project's main campaign is coming: You outline specific events and promotions that are planned and tell when they will happen.
The project's main campaign is here: You kick the project
off with a media event, hosted by a well-known local personality,
who has agreed to act as spokesperson.
The project's main campaign results: You release the results of the campaign and discuss future campaign plans.
The project receives awards or special recognition: Some
group, governmental agency, or publication recognizes your work.
Photographs: Get local photos of a variety of cyclists wearing helmets. Often, newspapers want to use black and white photographs with stories about helmets and it helps to have well-exposed prints they can use. Keep a list of people who wear helmets and don't mind having their pictures taken. The papers may want to take their own photos and talk to cyclists for human interest stories.
Working with the media
Each type of media has its uses. Here are some things to consider.
Using television is important to any campaign. It gets the word
out widely and lends credence to your project. There are several useful TV outlets:
News shows: Get to know the local reporters, particularly the ones who cover topics like yours. Contact them personally when you've got something happening.
Local community interest shows: Put together a list of shows and find out how much lead time they need to fit you into their schedules. It could easily take more than a month.
Public service announcements: Contact Harborview or Safe Kids for sources of helmet-related public service announcements. You might also consider producing several locally, with the cooperation of a local TV station. They may be willing to donate their work or give you a special community group rate. We have a page of PSA scripts on this disk. Using local kids and local scenes can make the spots more interesting. Work with the television stations to get your PSA's aired during popular viewing times; few people are watching at 3 AM.
One inexpensive PSA option is to simply prepare text to be read
on the air. TV stations often offer this option and it should
be used, although it's not as powerful or interesting as live-action video.
Since radio stations tend to focus on specific audiences, you
can target your messages more easily than on TV. Find out what
audiences your stations reach and use that information in preparing your mailings.
News shows: If the radio stations have local news staffs,
send them your news releases and press kits. Make sure you include a daytime phone number with your release so they can call you for quotes as needed.
Public service announcements: An easy way to do radio PSA
spots is to type them on 3x5 postcards and send to key radio people. Keep the spots short and sweet, with one subject per PSA. In this way, popular disc jockeys can read the announcements lending their voices to the campaign. Get to know radio personalities who appeal to your target audience. You may find a valuable ally, one willing to help with other parts of the project like emceeing an event.
Perhaps more than any other local media, the newspaper is an institution. Its importance in reaching your audience is often matched by the difficulty of getting coverage. Yet, it's worth the effort. Here are some ideas for focusing your efforts on the newspapers.
Columnists: Local columnists are often looking for something to write about. Identify each writer's focus (youth-oriented humor, social affairs etc.) and prepare a package with a slant for that person. If you approach columnists positively and give them enough information, they may write about your project or ideas. But don't just contact them once. Create an on-going relationship. Let them know whenever you've got something they might find interesting.
Letters: The Letters to the Editor column is the most popular part of many newspapers. Have one of your people write to the paper, outlining your concern for helmet use and your plans. Find people to write testimonial letters about the value of helmets. After an event write a letter thanking everyone for their help. And if you see any articles discussing helmets or bicycle safety, make sure someone writes in to give a local perspective.
You may find that nationally-syndicated columnists touch on safety issues occasionally. Also, national and international events (like an American cyclist's winning the Tour de France) can provide a focus for letters with positive helmet messages. Be careful with any letters you write after a tragic death from head injury. Some will accuse you of callously using the tragedy to advance a cause. Check your facts very carefully before writing a letter like that to be sure the lack of a helmet was actually the cause of death. Letters about stories on miraculous saves in bad crashes are probably a better bet.
News stories: Get to know reporters who cover your beat
(community affairs, the school beat, health issues, in particular). If you have an event planned or have just completed an accident study, let that person know. Such contacts are much more valuable than sending news releases to The Editor.
Special focus sections: Many newspapers run inserts focusing on special events or seasons. For example, they may publish a special Back To School Edition as the new school year
approaches. Getting an article on helmets into this section may
pay off handsomely. Ask for a list of all special sections and
Advertisements: Ask the paper for their policy on public
service ads. They may give you free space [as long as you don't, at the same time, buy time on TV or radio]. Also put together small "slugs" that advertisers can slip into their product ads. These would include your main slogan and a logo, and should be created in an assortment of sizes and printed on a "slick" (8.5 x 11 sheet of glossy paper).
Pay special attention to advertisers who appeal to your target
audience. For example, furniture store ads probably won't appeal to teenagers but may appeal to parents
Keep in mind that your community may have several important newspapers serving different groups of readers.
Search out any weekly entertainer-type publications or ethnically
oriented papers. These newspapers may well give you access to
an audience you might not reach through the mainstream media.
Many communities also have free advertiser-type newspapers.
These may be little more than collections of classified ads but
they often have some editorial content. Send them your news releases and materials.
Distributing helmet promotion materials
Posters and pamphlets can support the messages you get across
in your direct contacts and broaden your impact. Your materials
should be good looking, have acceptable messages, and be on-target. Although helmet promotion may be your point, a pamphlet or flyer on bicycle safety, with the helmet message included, may be a better approach to get widest distribution. Some communities are now producing information on how to use their bike trails and lanes, for example, with the helmet message in the body.
The links in Appendix A include information on ordering several pieces that you can use in your campaign for free. You will find sources for other materials listed there too, including some on the Internet. Some of the Bicycle Helmet Safety Institute pamphlets are included on this disk, listed on the Toolkit index page.
Consider buying a box of inexpensive plastic or cardboard brochure holders. If your pamphlets are cluttering a shop's countertop, customers may not pay attention to them and the shop owner may consider them a nuisance. A special holder solves this problem and gives your brochures more visibility and prominence.
Where to distribute pamphlets and posters
Doctor and dentist offices, clinics, and hospitals
Schools and parks
City buses and bus stops
Banks and savings and loans
Supermarkets and other large stores
Governmental offices and community TV centers
6.A Links to References and Contacts
6.B Sample survey
6.C Sample budgets for helmet projects
6.D Case Study #1: Seattle, Washington
6.E Case Study #2: Pitt Co., North Carolina
6.F Case Study #3: Palo Alto, California
6.G Case Study #4: Madison, Wisconsin
6.H Case Study #5: Missoula, Montana
6.A References and Contacts
6.B Sample Survey
This survey was conducted by the Pitt County Health Department
at the beginning of their helmet campaign. The full text of the
survey, as well as the post-program survey (with different questions) is available from the N.C.D.O.T. Bicycle Program. Bear in mind that many people responding to a survey tell the interviewer what they think the interviewer wants to hear.
1. How many children in your household are currently in grades
kindergarten through eighth and are attending a school in the
Pitt County School System?
2. Does your child ever use a skateboard, bicycle, tricycle, three-wheel all terrain vehicle, or four-wheel all terrain vehicle?
3. How frequently does (child's name) ride a bicycle when the
weather is good? Would you say that s/he rides it every day, every week, two to three times per month, or less than once per month?
4. Where does (child's name) ride his/her bicycle most often?
5. What is the longest distance (child's name) regularly rides?
Would you say it is within two blocks from home, more than two
blocks but less than a mile, or more than a mile from home?
6. Does (child's name) ever ride his/her bike to school?
7. Has (child's name) ever been injured on a bike badly enough
to be taken to a doctor's office or hospital?
8. Does (child's name) have a bicycle safety helmet?
9. Out of every ten times that (child's name) rides his/her bike,
how many times does s/he wear the bike helmet?
10. Can you tell me why (child's name) doesn't have a bicycle
11. Do you think you will buy a bike helmet for (child's name)
within the next six months?
12. Would you buy a helmet if (child's name) asked for one?
13. How important do you think it is that (child's name) wear
a bicycle helmet when s/he rides a bike? Would you say that it
is very important, important, not very important or not important
14. Which statement best describes (child's name) use of health
care? Sh/e goes to the doctor only when sick or injured, or s/he
goes to the doctor each year for a check-up in addition to when
s/he is sick or injured.
15. How important is it for bicyclists other than your children
to wear safety helmets? Would you say that it is very important,
important, not very important or not important at all?
16. Some parents may have concerns about their children as they
grow up. Besides illness and disease, what are some of the things
about your children you think about or worry about?
17. Just as your best guess, what would you say are the two leading types of accidents that cause death among children under age 14: Riding in a car that is hit, hit by a car while walking, drowning, burns or fires, other?
18. What is your race?
19. Are you male or female?
20. Are you currently married, single, divorced, separated, widowed, or something else?
21. What is the highest year of school that your spouse completed?
22. What is the highest year of school that you completed?
6C. Sample budgets for helmet projects
The following projects are examples of those submitted for
funding to the North Carolina Division of Maternal and Child Health, Office for Prevention. While these projects were funded under a federal grant no longer available, they show the kinds of things groups have included in their budgets. Keep in mind that you may be able to cover such costs through "in kind" contributions from businesses.
Project 1: Includes presentations to school PTA's, helmet drawings, presentations at churches and civic groups, bike rodeos, poster contests, school "helmet days," displays around town, media coverage and PSAs.
108 helmets @ $30 $3240.00
Rodeo supplies 100.00
Supplies (printing, postage for evaluations) 600.00
Project 2: Includes lessons for students in grades 6, 7, and
8, using audio visuals and community volunteers.
Competition awards (helmets reflectors, headlights, etc) 2500.00
Skills site preparation 200.00
Project 3: Includes safety training sessions, distribution
of materials, media campaign, and displays.
1000 Adult brochures $200.00
1000 Child brochures 200.00
25 Community Guides 25.00
1000 posters 200.00
2 Videos 50.00
1000 Promo reflective stickers 200.00
3 Promo news ads 450.00
Promo attendance prizes 350.00
170 $15.00 helmet discount coupons 2550.00
6D. Case Study #1: Seattle, Washington
Seattle is a large urbanized area in the Northwest. It is a rapidly growing center with an active outdoors-oriented population and is home of large aerospace and computer companies.
The helmet awareness campaign in Seattle, Washington, was aimed
primarily at elementary-aged school children.
1 ) a media campaign (primarily radio and television);
2) a discount helmet purchase arrangement in the schools;
3) elementary school assembly programs and bicycle rodeos featuring
the popular safety superhero Sprocketman;
4) helmet materials distributed through local physicians' offices;
5) encouragement brochures, stickers, posters, and other materials.
The campaign was designed and run by a coalition of 16 organizations,
spearheaded by two organizations with Web links if your Internet
connection is working, the Harborview Injury Prevention and Research Center and the
Cascade Bicycle Club. Other organizations in the coalition
included local TV station KOMO, MSR and Pro-Tec (local helmet
manufacturers), the Metrocenter YMCA, the Washington State Pediatric
Society, the Washington Academy of Family Physicians, and several
other state and regional groups. Much of the success of this on-going
helmet campaign is a result of a strong coalition that continues
to draw upon the diverse resources, experience, and expertise
of the individual coalition members.
Support and Donations:
Taking the lead in the Seattle helmet campaign was staff at the
Harborview Injury Prevention and Research Center.
Much of the original funding for the program came from Mountain
Safety Research (MSR), an early manufacturer of bicycle helmets.
In 1988, when MSR ceased production of cycling helmets, another
Seattle helmet manufacturer, Pro-Tec, stepped in to assist in
funding and providing helmets for various programs. Pro-Tec created a statewide helmet discount buying program tied to the helmet coalition's work. Prices were lowered from $39-$55 to around $25 for each helmet.
Many other campaign services, such as production of PSAs, were
donated by the KOMO-TV public service department and other local film production companies. The free television PSAs produced for the coalition were valued at more than $60.000.00.
Professional staff and volunteers:
At an early point in the campaign, Harborview enlisted the aid
of the Cascade Bicycle Club; at that time Jane Abraham, a member of the bicycle club's board of directors, was hired by Harborview as a consultant to the helmet project.
For the first two years of the project, decisions were made by
the coalition. As the program grew, it was clear that a full-time coordinator was needed. When Abraham became a consultant to the Cascade Bicycle Club (1988), she also assumed duties as campaign coordinator. (Deborah Richards, a health educator with Harborview, took over as campaign coordinator in the fall of 1987.)
In addition to the full-time coordinator, much time was donated
to the project by staff of the various coalition members. Several volunteers who were never recognized publicly, simply because they wore masks as part of their presentation, were the men who don Sprocketman costumes to visit elementary school assemblies and bicycle rodeos.
Originally a cycling superhero comic book character developed
for the bike safety program at Stanford University in Palo Alto, California, Sprocketman was brought to life by a core of
dedicated Seattle volunteers. Wearing his colorful Iycra costume, Sprocketman is in constant demand from area schools, and yet the coalition has never had to advertise this part of their encouragement program-it's all been word of mouth.
Initial data was gathered in 1986 by a Harborview summer research assistant, Carla Pharris. She surveyed Seattle pediatricians to learn how many of their patients age 12 and under wore bicycle helmets. The discouraging answer was only 1 percent. A second observational survey in May of 1987 found that five percent of children aged 12 and under in King County (which includes Seattle and surrounding environs) used helmets.
Based on the latter data, the coalition chose the goal of reducing bike-related head injuries through four objectives:
1) Increase general community awareness of the problem of bicycle-related head injuries;
2) Educate parents, especially those of young children, about
the problem, and provide information on how they could protect
3) Address the peer pressure issue by making bicycle helmets acceptable;
4) Ensure that low-cost helmets were made available.
One measurement of the campaign's success was the increase in
Pro-Tec helmet sales. In a two-year period (1986-88), statewide
sales increased from 1,500 helmets to 20,000 helmets. More than
5,000 helmet sales could be traced directly to the coupon program. Another 1,500 helmets donated by Pro-Tec were distributed for $5 each to children of low-income families.
The public education campaign has also met with great success.
In 1988 alone, PTAs invited Sprocketman to visit 41 elementary
schools, and address nearly 19,000 kids.
Also at the request of the PTAs, the Cascade Bicycle Club started offering bicycle rodeos at elementary schools. There was almost too much success here: the club ran 28 rodeos in 1988, and had many more requests. Given the response, Cascade members have started training PTA groups to do their own rodeos.
The Seattle campaign's careful coalition building, linking physicians, cycling organizations, the media, and helmet manufacturers, assured success of the project. At the same time, the lead on the program was retained by the originators (Harborview), which worked closely with other coalition members, using each group's strengths to mount a very successful campaign.
Begun in 1986, the Seattle helmet campaign is an on-going project, which has grown to reach most areas of the state of Washington. It has also influenced many other programs nationwide.
For further information, contact the Helmet Program Coordinator, Harborview Injury Prevention and Research Center, 2559 NE 83rd St., Seattle WA 98115 (206) 522-4766
6E. Case Study #2: Pitt County, North Carolina
Pitt County, North Carolina, is a rural farm-oriented area with
an urban center. The City of Greenville is the home of one campus of the University of North Carolina system, housing a medical school and other centers of higher learning.
This program, which involved a number of agencies, was designed
to increase bicycle helmet use by children aged 5 to 14 in Pitt
County, North Carolina.
1) A pre-program telephone survey to gauge helmet use;
2) A media campaign to increase parent awareness;
3) A campaign in the public schools;
4) A discount coupon for helmet purchase;
5) A post-program follow-up survey to gauge program effectiveness.
Numerous agencies and groups were involved as a coalition backing the Pitt County Bicycle Helmet Promotion Project. The program was administered by the Department of Health, Environment, and Natural Resources, through that agency's Office for Prevention. Participating groups and agencies included: Pitt County Health Department.; local pediatricians and family practitioners; the local police department; emergency medical services; local bicycle retailers; the agricultural extension; and the Recreation and Parks Department. In addition, the project enjoyed media support from the local television and radio stations.
Funding for the program came from a grant from the Centers for
Disease Control, for prevention of developmental disabilities
(head injuries) in children.
Support and donations:
The program was broken down into four target areas: media, schools, health professionals, and the community at large.
The media campaign included brochures, a press kit for radio,
television, and newspapers, public service announcements for the electronic media, posters, and a campaign kick-off press conference.
In the schools, the coalition reached children and their parents through PTA programs, flyers directed at the parents, and contests.
Pediatricians and family practitioners received brochures for
their offices, as well as additional information for use in counseling parents during child visits.
In the community, the coalition structured a speakers bureau,
and used it to carry the helmet promotion message to civic and
service organizations (Optimists, Rotary, etc.), and others. The local bike shop also took part in a discount coupon program. Although not planned as a key part of the project, the discount program was very successful. Coupons were distributed for a low-cost Pro-Tec helmet, redeemed at the local bicycle shop. Distribution was done in day care centers, schools, factories, medical and dental offices, and even through the newspaper. The Coalition distributed coupons during two four-month periods: once early in the project and again about a year later. Parents redeemed over 570 helmet coupons for their children. In addition, the shop owner reported that parents also bought helmets for themselves.
Professional staff and volunteers:
The Coalition was led by a full-time professional coordinator
working for the Pitt County Health Department.
Pre-program data was gathered by the North Carolina Division of
Statistics and Information Services through a detailed contact
form. The text took the telephone survey worker through 22 questions. Potential respondents were interviewed only if they had children in kindergarten through eighth grade.
For a summary of the questions used in the pre-program survey,
see Appendix 6-B above.
In the pre-program survey, only a few children reported having
helmets (about 6 percent) and parents did not specify that these were bicycle safety helmets. The post-program survey, conducted in June 1990, showed the impact of this successful effort. Bicycle helmet ownership by children had risen to 16 percent. Many more parents agreed that helmets were necessary and 30 percent planned to buy one within the next six months. Over one third of the families had heard of the Pitt County Project, mostly through schools, public service announcements on radio and TV, and the newspapers.
The outstanding feature of the Pitt County helmet project was
the wide base of support gained through successful coalition building. With the media, schools, community leaders, and health professionals all pushing for success, it would have been surprising if the project had not met with wide acceptance.
Another component was the slide tape developed to show to adult
audiences, such as PTA groups, civic associations, etc. The presentation was developed by Eastern Carolina University.
They also secured the cooperation of a local billboard advertising company, who allowed the campaign to post their messages for two years in two different locations around the county.
An evaluation report was prepared showing the effectiveness of
For further information, and an update on the final project report, contact the N.C.D.O.T. Bicycle Program, P.O. Box 25201, Raleigh, NC 27611; (919) 733-2804.
6F. Case Study #3: Palo Alto, California
Palo Alto, California, is a university town in the center of the Silicon Valley. It is home to Stanford University and many high-tech computer companies.
Bette Coan focused on students from kindergarten up to seniors
in high school. "I knew I could convince parents to get helmets," she said, "but that wouldn't get them on their [the children's] heads."
She developed three age-specific programs: one each for kindergarten, grades one through three, and grades four through six. She also spoke at local industries and encouraged bicycle commuters there to buy and wear helmets.
Bette made personal presentations to local schools, most often to more than one class at a time in mini-assemblies. A typical day included two presentations, each 45 minutes long with a film, Bette's talk about bicycle safety, and a question-and-answer period.
She showed a film called "Ride On By," borrowed from
the Santa Barbara Police Department that graphically detailed
the results of bicycle accidents. She also used a film entitled
"Cyclists Don't Have to Have Accidents." After the presentation, she gave students order blanks for helmets at a discount price. Students would take the blanks home for their parents to use in ordering.
Bette already had begun working toward increasing helmet wear
among young students when she learned that the local Council of
PTAs needed a Safety Committee Chairperson. She volunteered, and for several years continued as Chairperson.
Support and donations:
In 1980, Bell Helmets offered a discount for orders of 50 helmets or more. Bette ordered helmets directly from Bell and then distributed them to students who had placed orders and paid for their helmets. Neither Bette nor the PTA made money from the helmet sales. As further enticement, Bette convinced a local fast food restaurant to offer a free hamburger to each helmet purchaser.
Professional staff and volunteers:
A successful bicycle helmet campaign can happen through the efforts of just one person. Bette Coan of Palo Alto, California, is a case in point. Bicycle safety became extremely important to Bette after her son suffered partial brain damage from a bicycling accident. Seeing her son wear a helmet during his therapy, Bette decided that young cyclists needed to wear helmets.
In the spring of 1980, Bette launched a drive in Palo Alto schools to promote bike helmet use among young students. She told students that one day, wearing a bicycle helmet will be a status symbol "because those that wear them are smarter than those that don't."
Unfortunately, there are no detailed figures for Bette's program or for the number of bike helmets sold. In the spring of 1980 however, Bette sold over 500 bike helmets to students. After a school presentation, Bette would occasionally sell around 200 helmets. During the course of her helmet promotion program, Bette sold close to 10,000 bicycle helmets.
Bette believed that repeated helmet presentations and promotions were needed. Encouraged by the response from her Spring 1980 campaign, Bette followed up with a fall campaign covering the same schools and grades. Bette continued with her helmet promotion in Palo Alto schools for several years. Her helmet campaign was so successful that a new problem emerged: finding space for all the helmets. Consequently, school personnel built shelves specifically for bike helmets.
After years of effort, she was honored by the Palo Alto Unified
School District for "persuading close to 10,000 children
to use bicycle helmets." Through the years, Bette Coan provided
an excellent bike safety role model.
At times it is difficult to overcome deep-seated attitudes about life and death among young students. "Children really have the feeling of immortality. They always think it's going to be someone else," Bette said. "I try to tell them that broken bones mend, but once you mess around with that gray matter, you've had it." Because of her own work and determination, Bette Coan had a tremendous effect on bicycle safety for children in Palo Alto.
For years, Bette ran her program through Palo Alto's elementary
and middle schools. When she died of cancer in the mid-1980s,
other parents took over where she left off.
Ellen Fletcher, 777-108 San Antonio Rd., Palo Alto CA 94303
6G. Case Study #4: Madison, Wisconsin
Madison, Wisconsin, is a medium-sized city in the Midwest. It
is the home of the University of Wisconsin and is the State's
The Madison, Wisconsin, helmet campaign targeted the entire riding
population-approximately 150,000 bicyclists. A pre-campaign survey
showed that 90 percent of Madison bicyclists did not wear helmets.
The campaign had two objectives:
1) To reach a significant proportion of Madison bicyclists;
2) To increase the use of helmets among those cyclists.
The campaign used a variety of media-television, radio, newspapers,
brochures, and posters-to reach the target audience with it's
helmet use message. Discount prices supported some of the messages.
A coalition of local health care organizations, bicycle clubs,
and city and state agencies sponsored the campaign.
Support and donations:
A news conference kicking off the campaign featured Madison Mayor
F. Joseph Sensenbrenner, whose message was supported by injury
data presented by a local physician. Three radio stations and
one television station attended the news conference. The local
bicycle club's Bike Month publicity materials mentioned the campaign,
as did publications of several health care organizations. The
Capital Times newspaper carried editorials and several news features.
Professional staff and volunteers:
Steve Berchem, Madison's then bicycle coordinator, was heavily
involved in developing and operating the campaign. The coalition
developed a radio public service announcement (PSA) which they
distributed to local stations. The campus station, and local TV
and radio stations also aired interviews with a coalition members.
At the state level, the Wisconsin Department of Transportation
(DOT) produced two television PSAs on helmet use-one for young
adults, the other for parents. They then distributed the PSAs
to local stations.
Madison-area bike club ride organizers were also active in the
campaign. Ride leaders for the Bombay Bicycle Club stressed helmets
during pre-ride instructions. The club also offered $5.00 rebates
to the first 100 cyclists submitting proof of helmet purchase
during the campaign. Though they feared being swamped with responses,
the club received only 85 rebate requests. The Madison Bicycle
Brigade ran tickets for a drawing in a Bike Month calendar and
on flyers distributed by the police department. The winner received
a discount on a helmet purchase. This program brought 219 responses.
A Madison market research firm did both a pre- and post-campaign
survey to judge effectiveness in reaching cyclists and encouraging
helmet use. In the pre-campaign survey, 300 adult bicyclists randomly
selected through the phone book were asked:
(1) Do you ride mainly for recreation or transportation; (2) Are
you a recent bike accident victim, or do you know someone who
is; (3) What is your educational background and income; (4) How
old are you; (5) How far and how often do you ride; (6) Do you
wear a helmet, and if not, why not; (7) Where do you get your
bicycle safety information.
For the purposes of the survey, a "bicyclist" was defined
as an adult who had bicycled at least once during the previous
year. In households with more than one cycling adult in a sampled
household, the more active cyclist was interviewed. Surveyors
also recorded demographics. Half of the population sample used
were male, and half were female. All interviews were conducted
Results of the pre- and post-campaign surveys were published in
Bicycle Forum 17, available through Bikecentennial. To establish
a base level of helmet use, coalition members made counts of helmeted
cyclists at four intersections before and after the campaign.
Based on the pre-campaign survey, 19 percent of the sample owned
a helmet, but only 12 percent usually wore it. 35 percent of those
who did not own helmets said they did not need them, and 32 percent
said they'd never thought about wearing one. The pre-campaign
traffic counts during a one-week period tallied 15 percent of
the cyclists wearing helmets.
According to the post-campaign survey, 47 percent of the sample
(again half male, half female) recalled reading, seeing, or hearing
something about bicycle helmets during the previous six weeks.
More than one-third remembered seeing something in the newspaper;
one-fifth recalled seeing one of the television PSAs. And, finally,
the second intersection count showed 19 percent of the cyclists
spotted wearing helmets.
Ten bicycle shops participated to some extent in the campaign.
One dealer reported no increase in sales, six noted increases
of from 15 percent to 200 percent over the previous May's sales,
and three would not comment on sales levels.
The campaign reached some 50,000 bicyclists, and encouraged perhaps
5,000 to wear helmets. Berchem felt that additional planning prior
to the campaign would have helped, and that the campaign should
have lasted longer than six weeks.
The results suggested that price was not the primary barrier to
buying or wearing a helmet. It was felt that rebate money could
have been better spent on other promotions.
Much time was spent in developing the campaign theme. The coalition
decided that it should (a) be a short, comprehensive slogan that
could be used in all media efforts; (b) tie various messages directly
to the campaign; (c) be positive; (d) lend itself to visual presentations,
but make sense without supporting visual aids (e.g., for radio
PSAs). The chosen theme was "Be A Well-Dressed Cyclist-Wear
Several campaign components featured bicyclists dressed in formal
wear and sporting helmets. The fashion element showed off the
new breed of lighter, comfortable, and attractive helmets available.
This campaign was run as a onetime project. However, in recent
years other helmet campaigns have happened in Madison.
For reprints of the survey and a more in-depth article about the
Madison campaign, send an SASE and $1.00 to cover cost of copying
and handling to Bicycle Forum, Bikecentennial, P.O. Box 8308,
Missoula, MT 59807 ().
For additional information concerning Madison's campaign, contact
Arthur Ross, Madison Bicycle Coordinator, 215 Martin Luther King
Blvd., Madison W1 53710: (608) 266-6225.
Case Study #5: Missoula, Montana
Missoula, Montana, is a small university town in the Northern
Rocky Mountains. It's economy is closely tied to the ups and downs
of the timber industry.
In its first year, 1982, the Missoula helmet program focused primarily
on elementary aged school children (K-8th grade). More than 8,000
children were reached through the school system. In subsequent
years, the focus broadened somewhat to reach older riders as well.
The Missoula program involved two key components:
1) A media campaign, including the production of a series of television
2) A discount helmet purchasing program.
The media campaign involved work with the local paper, radio stations,
and television stations. One special focus was on the production
of a television PSA series. A news release sent to schools, children's
organizations, and local media outlets invited children to help
create the PSAs. Thirty children volunteered to take part in the
production. The spots were written by city bike program staff.
The series included a 60-second and a 30-second spot, both in
an "interview format," and a 10-second animated spot.
Costs for the location filming, editing, and basic studio work
came to approximately $120.00 for the series, at the TV station's
public service rate.
The helmet purchasing program involved distributing coupon sheets
through all of the elementary schools (public and private) in
the Missoula area.
Each bicycle shop that participated in the program got to use
one coupon on the sheet. In this way, each shop could choose which
helmets to list, and what price to charge.
Given the information, the parent and child could review the choices
and prices, and then go shopping. A deadline date was placed on
the coupon to avoid having the program drift on forever. Discounts
ranged between 10 and 25 percent; the least expensive helmet cost
$28, the most expensive offered through the program cost $37.
The program was developed and operated by the City of Missoula
Bicycle Program, with the cooperation and assistance of six local
bicycle shops and the public and private schools of Missoula.
Support and donations:
The coupon printing, PSA development and filming, and time spent
on media development were all paid for from the Missoula bike
program's small budget.
Professional staff and volunteers:
John Williams, at that time the city bicycle coordinator for Missoula,
oversaw the program. Staff support was provided by work-study
employees of the bicycle program as well as by individual volunteers.
The helmet coupon sheet used to advertise the program also served
as the response tracking device. The bike shops were asked to
save the coupons as they were redeemed by students and parents.
The coupons also carried space for the helmet purchaser's name,
address, and school. Those who filled in this information were
sent a follow-up survey with questions concerning helmet usage
and peer attitudes about bicycle helmets.
The coupons were distributed to the schools in mid-May. Around
the first of July, redeemed coupons were collected from the shops.
The campaign resulted in the sale of 249 helmets in three and
a half weeks. Most of the helmets were purchased for students;
some coupons were redeemed for helmets to be worn by the parents.
Following the spring helmet campaign, program staff sent a survey
in the late fall to the 180 names collected from the coupons.
Two months were allowed for returns, which numbered 73. A few
results: the largest group (36 percent) of respondents were children
between the ages of 8 and 11. Cyclists under the age of 8 (including
infants whose parents completed the survey) comprised 26 percent of the
sample; 20 percent were between 12 and 14 years, and 18 percent were older than
14. Other questions covered peer response to helmets, why the
child chose to wear a helmet, and what they liked or didn't like
about their helmet.
Based on the success of the initial campaign, the helmet coupon
program has been continued in subsequent years. The distribution
of coupons to the schools each spring is now routine. Falling
prices on helmets have lessened the impact of the annual campaigns,
but helmets continue to be sold. You can walk into any bike shop
in Missoula today and find a variety of bicycle helmets for children
(and all ages), and this was not the case when the city bike program
ran its initial helmet awareness and coupon campaigns.
John Williams, now of Tracy-Williams Consulting, published an article concerning the Missoula helmet campaign in Bicycle Forum Issue #15, Spring 1987. If your Internet connection is working
you can contact John at The BikePlan Source
Otherwise, his address is Tracy-Williams Consulting, PO Box 8311, Missoula, MT 59807 and
his telephone is (406) 543-8113.
This page was reformatted on: October 11, 2017.