Helmets do not increase jaw injuries
Summary: A German study found that helmets increase jaw injuries. We disagree.
A 2016 German study conducted at the Hannover Medical School has found:
"The use of bicycle helmets does not significantly reduce the incidence of mid-facial fractures, while being correlated
with an even increased incidence of mandibular fractures."
The study was based on data on 5,350 crashes, with 537 wearing helmets (10%) and 4813 not wearing helmets. There were 18
jaw fractures, broken down as 5 with helmets (0.09%) and 13 without helmets (0.02%). So the authors concluded that
helmets cause jaw injures. That seems like a stretch to us based on 5 crashes.
Their explanation grossly oversimplifies the crash scenario:
"At the time of crash the helmet hides first. Afterwards the unprotected mandible crashed because of the hyperflexion in
the cervical spine." Anecdotal evidence indicates that the chin often hits before the helmet is even involved.
And finally, the authors acknowledge:
"The strongest limitation of our study was the small number of persons with helmet protection. So, the statistical
analysis was vulnerable for coincidence and bias. We also had 911 cases (17%) with missing data of the speed and did not
know what kind of helmet was worn. Second, we were unaware of the exact location of the fractures. Therefore, it is
difficult to separate the possible effect of the helmet on different fracture types. Furthermore, this fact hindered
comparison of our data with those of other studies."
Our conclusion is that this study did not demonstrate what the authors said it did. Many other studies have found that
bicycle helmets do offer some protection for the mid-face, but do not have an effect on jaw injuries. That seems to make
more sense.
The full study was on archtrauma.com but we don't find it any more.